12/11/2026

Alumni mentoring: how to set up a programme that really engages participants

Alumni mentoring is one of the few schemes that benefits students, graduates and the university alike. Yet many programmes run out of steam after a few weeks: mismatched pairs, meetings that don’t…

Alumni mentoring is one of the few schemes that benefits students, graduates and the university alike. Yet many programmes run out of steam after a few weeks: mismatched pairs, missed meetings, mentors being approached without a clear framework, and a lack of follow-up. For an alumni or corporate relations manager, the question is therefore not whether to launch a mentoring programme, but how to structure it so that it is sustainable in the long term. This guide sets out the method step by step, drawing on the schemes published by HEC Alumni, ESSEC Alumni and Sciences Po.

 

What is alumni mentoring?

Alumni mentoring refers to a supportive relationship between an experienced graduate – the mentor – and a student or recent graduate from the same institution – the mentee. The mentor shares their experience, offers guidance on career choices, provides access to their professional network and helps prepare for the search for an internship or job. The relationship is voluntary, time-limited and organised by the school, the alumni association, or both.

It differs from academic tutoring, which focuses on academic success, and from coaching, which is based on a professional approach and is often paid. Its strength lies in the sense of belonging: the mentor supports someone who has followed the same course of study as them, and the mentee gains a practical insight into what their network can offer them even before they graduate.

The impact of a mentor on career progression is well documented. According to the 2014 Gallup-Purdue Index, which surveyed more than 30,000 US graduates, those who recall both a mentor who encouraged them and lecturers who went out of their way to support them are more than twice as likely to be engaged in their work. Only 14 per cent of the graduates surveyed had experienced all three forms of support, highlighting the gap between the value of such support and its actual uptake.

For a school, mentoring is also a way of engaging alumni. It gives graduates a practical and rewarding role, making it one of the key tools for fostering an alumni network beyond one-off events.

 

Alumni mentoring formats to combine

The grandes écoles no longer offer a single programme, but a range of formats tailored to the needs of participants and the availability of mentors. The HEC Alumni mentoring page lists eight such programmes, ranging from six-month mentoring schemes to one-off advice sessions.

Format Published example Duration Public sector
Long-term one-to-one mentoring Alumni Mentoring, HEC Alumni 6 months Graduates and students
Cohort-based student mentoring Student mentoring, ESSEC Career Services and ESSEC Alumni 6 months per matching period ESSEC students
Peer mentoring Leadership through the Compagnonnage, HEC Paris 3 months Pairs of alumni and students, mentors with at least five years’ experience
Targeted mentoring for equal opportunities Mentoring of scholarship students, HEC Paris 1 year Around 60 scholarship students a year
Course-based mentoring MIF Mentoring and Finance Major, HEC Paris Academic year 160 to 170 students and 80 to 100 mentors per year
Thematic mentoring Women & Society Programme, Sciences Po 5 months 50 recent female graduates and 50 female professionals
Mentoring Update Mentoring Update, HEC Alumni 30 minutes to 1 hour A one-off, specific requirement
Group mentoring Speed mentoring, Sciences Po Careers Short session in small groups International recent graduates

Combining a long-term and a short-term format makes it possible to engage two types of mentor: those who can commit for several months and those who only have an hour to spare. Targeted programmes, such as mentoring for scholarship holders or female graduates, in turn fulfil the mission of equal opportunities that universities emphasise in their strategies.

 

Read more: HEC Inspire: the dinner that brings students and business leaders together

 

Setting up an alumni mentoring programme in five steps

1. Define the objective and the target audience

A mentoring programme that tries to do everything achieves nothing. The first decision concerns the target audience (students on a particular course, recent graduates, scholarship holders, alumni seeking a career change) and the expected outcome: entry into the labour market, choice of specialisation, business start-up, or international exposure. This choice determines the profile of the mentors to be recruited, the duration of the programme and the success indicators.

HEC Paris’s programme-specific mentoring scheme provides a good example of this. Launched in 2016 for students on the Master’s in Finance and the Finance Major at the Grande École, it brings together mentors from these very same courses. The objective is clear, the pool of mentors is well-suited to the programme, and each year the scheme supports 160 to 170 students with 80 to 100 mentors, equating to approximately two mentees per mentor.

2. Organise the matching process

Matching determines the quality of the relationship. There are three methods: allocation by the alumni team, selection by the mentee, and matching facilitated by a platform based on detailed profiles. In HEC Paris’s programme, students choose their mentors based on several criteria (employer, role, alma mater, nationality, place of work) and rank ten mentors in order of preference.

At ESSEC, mentors and mentees complete a profile on the MENTORING by ESSEC platform before each matching period. The questions are mainly in English, but answers can be written in either French or English, which opens up the programme to graduates living abroad. Whichever method is used, giving the mentee some say in the process strengthens their commitment right from the start.

3. Draw up a charter and set out the minimum commitment

The mentoring charter sets out what each party undertakes to do: the frequency of contact, the confidentiality of information shared, the duration of the mentoring relationship, how to proceed in the event of difficulties, and the requirement not to seek any commercial benefit in return. It protects both parties and provides the school with a clear basis for taking action if a mentoring pairing is not working out.

AlumNow — animez et fédérez votre réseau AlumniAlumNow — la plateforme CRM dédiée aux réseaux Alumni

The minimum commitment must be quantified. ESSEC’s student mentoring programme sets a target of around one exchange per month and requires three compulsory meetings between the student and their mentor. The HEC Paris scholarship programme provides for one meeting or online exchange per month, lasting an average of one hour. These simple guidelines help to avoid the two classic pitfalls: the mentor being overwhelmed and the mentee not daring to follow up.

The data collected for matching purposes (career history, employer, contact details) is subject to data protection legislation. The applicable rules are set out in our GDPR and alumni data guide.

4. Set the duration and timetable

The most common duration is between three and six months: three months for the HEC Paris mentoring scheme, five months for Sciences Po’s ‘Women & Society’ programme, and six months for the HEC Alumni Mentoring scheme and for each term of the ESSEC student mentoring programme. Any longer than that, commitment tends to wane; any shorter, the relationship does not have time to yield results.

The timetable must follow that of the students. ESSEC is organising two cohorts for the 2026–2027 academic year, running from December 2026 to June 2027 and from March to September 2027, which allows us to accommodate students who are undertaking work placements or studying abroad in the first semester. The Sciences Po Law School programme forms its pairs in the autumn term, with enrolment closing in early October, to support students throughout the academic year.

5. Monitor the mentoring pairs and engage the community of mentors

A programme without follow-up relies entirely on the goodwill of the pairs. The most well-organised schools arrange group progress reviews: the HEC Paris scholarship mentoring programme brings its mentors together twice a year – in March after the launch, and then before the summer for a mid-term review. The ESSEC platform incorporates messaging and video conferencing and enables the Career Services and ESSEC Alumni teams to monitor these exchanges.

Fostering interaction amongst mentors is just as valuable: sharing best practice, publicly recognising their commitment, and inviting them to school events. The tool chosen to manage the directory, matching and follow-up plays a key role at this stage, as our analysis of alumni network management platforms shows.

 

Key performance indicators for managing a mentoring programme

Measuring the success of a mentoring programme is not limited to the number of mentoring pairs formed. Useful indicators cover the entire process, from the recruitment of mentors to satisfaction at the end of the programme, and form part of the broader dashboards described in our guide to measuring the ROI of an alumni network.

Indicator What it measures How to work it out Time of measurement
Coverage rate Ability to meet demand Mentor-mentee pairs / mentees End of matching
Ratio of mentees per mentor The burden on mentors Number of mentees / number of active mentors End of matching
Activation rate The pairs have now officially started work Pairs who have been on a first date / pairs who have got together One month after the launch
Completion rate Compliance with the minimum commitment Pairs who attended all scheduled meetings / pairs formed End of cycle
Mutual satisfaction Quality as perceived by both parties Mentor and Mentee Questionnaire Mid-term and end of cycle
Mentor re-engagement rate Volunteer retention Re-registered mentors / mentors from the previous cohort Next cohort
Impact on integration Impact on career paths Comparison of employment outcomes between mentees and non-mentees Integration survey

The mentor re-engagement rate is often the most telling indicator. A mentor who re-enrols has found the experience valuable and becomes an ambassador for the programme amongst their cohort. Conversely, high turnover points to a problem with the framework, the matching process or recognition.

 

Examples of alumni mentoring schemes at the grandes écoles

The HEC Paris programme illustrates this tiered approach. Alongside the six-month Alumni Mentoring scheme, the school and its students’ association offer ‘flash mentoring’, work placement tutoring, peer mentoring, the ‘Parcours Engagement’ programme for first-year students (one tutor for around fifteen students), the business consultancy mentoring community (three virtual meetings between September and April) and mentoring for scholarship holders. Each format is tailored to a different audience and level of commitment, enabling the school to engage a large proportion of the HEC alumni network, as detailed on the HEC Paris page on Planète Grandes Écoles.

The ESSEC model is based on joint management by the school’s Career Services and ESSEC Alumni, supported by a community of over 180 mentors drawn from a network of more than 64,000 graduates. The dedicated platform centralises registration, matching and follow-up, and the expected commitment is clearly set out: three compulsory meetings and around one exchange per month.

At Sciences Po, several programmes run in parallel, tailored to different groups. The Women & Society programme pairs 50 recent female graduates with 50 female professionals for five months, with the aim of promoting equality right from the start of their careers. Graduates covered by the Priority Education Agreement are mentored in pairs by alumni. Finally, the Law School forms up to 100 pairs of students and legal professionals each year, a programme that has been running for six years.

 

Common mistakes in an alumni mentoring programme

The first mistake is to recruit too many mentees for too few mentors. A mentor who is supporting four or five students at the same time can no longer offer a personalised relationship, and that is precisely what makes the scheme so valuable. The ratio must be set before the scheme is launched, even if this means limiting the number of places.

The second issue stems from the lack of a written agreement. With no charter or minimum number of meetings, each party waits for the other to take the initiative, and the relationship fizzles out after an initial exchange. The third is a lack of follow-up: at the end of the year, the alumni team discovers that half of the pairs have never met, and they have been unable to reassign the mentees.

Finally, many schools forget to thank their mentors. A message at the end of the academic year, an invitation to an exclusive event or a mention in the association’s newsletter costs very little and can influence whether mentors re-enrol the following year. Mentors who feel valued are also the graduates most likely to support the school in other ways, including during alumni fundraising campaigns.

 

FAQ on alumni mentoring

How long should an alumni mentoring programme last?

The programmes run by the grandes écoles usually last between three and six months: three months for the HEC Paris mentoring scheme, five months for Sciences Po’s ‘Women & Society’ programme, and six months for HEC’s Alumni Mentoring scheme and ESSEC’s student mentoring scheme. Programmes aimed at scholarship holders sometimes run for a full year, as is the case at HEC Paris.

How many meetings should be scheduled between a mentor and their mentee?

The most common benchmark is one exchange per month. ESSEC’s student mentoring programme sets a target of around one exchange per month and requires three compulsory meetings. The HEC Paris scholarship programme provides for one meeting or online exchange per month, lasting an average of one hour. The format (video call, telephone call or face-to-face meeting) is generally left to the discretion of the pair.

How should mentor-mentee pairs be formed?

There are three methods: assignment by the alumni team, selection by the mentee, and platform-assisted matching. In HEC Paris’s finance programme, students rank ten mentors in order of preference based on criteria such as employer, role or place of work. Allowing the mentee some say in the choice helps to boost their engagement.

How many mentees should be assigned to a single mentor?

There is no single rule, but the relationship loses its personalised nature when a mentor supervises too many students. The HEC Paris Finance programme has 160 to 170 students and 80 to 100 mentors, which works out at around two mentees per mentor. Group-based programmes, such as HEC Paris’s Parcours Engagement, on the other hand, typically have one tutor for around fifteen students.

Is a dedicated platform needed to manage mentoring?

A programme involving a few dozen pairs can get started using forms and a spreadsheet. For larger programmes, a platform makes it easier for the team to manage registration, matching, messaging and follow-up. ESSEC uses MENTORING by ESSEC, and several programmes at HEC Paris rely on My Job Glasses Experience.

 

Key takeaways

A truly engaging alumni mentoring programme is based on five key elements: a specific objective and target audience; a matching process that gives the mentee a say in the choice; a charter setting out a minimum, quantified commitment; a duration of three to six months aligned with the academic calendar; and active monitoring of the mentoring pairs. The schemes run by HEC Paris, ESSEC and Sciences Po demonstrate the value of combining several formats to engage mentors with varying levels of availability. Managed using a few simple indicators – from activation rates to mentor re-engagement – mentoring is becoming one of the most effective ways of keeping an alumni network alive.

Share this article: